University Libraries Help How do I? All FAQs What's the difference between a magazine and a scholarly journal?

What's the difference between a magazine and a scholarly journal?

— filed under: ,

Scholarly Journals

  • Generally have a serious look.
  • Often contain pictures, graphs, and charts.
  • Written by “experts” in particular fields (subject disciplines).
  • Report on original research or experimentation.
  • Often reviewed (refereed) by author’s peers before publication.
  • Intended audience is other scholars (researchers, professors, students) and “experts” familiar with the language of the discipline.
  • Credit given to sources used (i.e., citations).
    • In-text citations
    • Bibliography or reference list
    • Footnotes or endnotes
  • Published by academic presses or endorsed by professional associations.

Popular Magazines

  • Available in many formats.
  • Often attractive in appearance
  • Often contain many photographs and other eye-catching graphics.
  • Generally written by professional writers or journalists
  • Generally not written by scholarly “experts” in any one field.
  • Intended audience is the general public.
  • Language used is simple and entertaining.
  • Rarely credit their sources (i.e., no citations).
  • Published by commercial presses.
  • Contain advertisements.
  • Can be purchased at newsstands, grocery stores, and large bookstores.
Document Actions
Giving to the Libraries